What the Goldman Sachs Letter Was Really About

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

One of the highlights of my reading this week was the resignation letter published in the New York Times by Greg Smith, a promising young executive with Goldman Sachs who decided he had had enough with a corporate culture he felt had devolved to the point that he had to get out.  And he thought it necessary to share this with millions of readers the world over.

I read the letter, the rebuttal from Goldman Sachs and some of the online commentary.  I have to say, I found it all fascinating and terrifying.

Fascinating, because a single individual was given a global platform to indict one of Wall Street’s most revered brands.  It’s one thing for a person to post such a letter on the web – that happens all the time.  What was it about this person, this letter, this company that led the Times to provide the writer with one of the world’s biggest bullhorns?  I would have loved to have been a fly on the wall for that discussion by the Editorial Board – much less the office of the General Counsel.

Terrifying, because in today’s digital world, given the right circumstances, a single person has the power to destroy a brand by writing what is essentially an opinion piece disguised as a letter of resignation.  Or maybe disguised as a job application, as some have suggested.  I have no clue whether Mr. Smith’s accusations have any merit.  How could I?  But reading through the comments associated with the piece, most people believed every word he said.

I found Goldman’s response predictable and weak.  But with accusations like these, what can one say?  Who has a worse job at Goldman’s than the poor soul who had to draft that statement?  What are your choices?  He’s a disgruntled employee.  It’s just a few bad apples.  We’re not as bad as our competitors.

As with all things digital, I wonder about the long-term impact of this kind of thing.  Can one letter really kill the company’s entire campus recruiting effort, as some have suggested?  I read a quote from a young person who said he was so disillusioned by the letter he decided not to apply for a job at Goldman but instead has decided to pursue his passion for the theatre.  Honestly?  Was that guy really going to Goldman Sachs?

The only thing I know for certain is that it is harder and harder for people, corporations, institutions, governments, etc. to cultivate and maintain a benevolent image while behaving in the exact opposite way from their supposed values.  To be sure, they can do it for a while.  In fact, some have raised it to an art form.  But sooner or later, someone with a good internet connection and a flair for writing can bring the whole thing crashing down.

And by and large, I think this is probably a good thing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Don’t Be A Stranger…

Just write down some details and our customer success heroes will get back to you in a jiffy!

Contact Info